CRITIQUING CHARACTERS (GROK-AI RESPONSE) FURTHER PSYCHOANALYSIS OF TONY SOPRANO'S GHOST

CRITIQUING CHARACTERS

(GROK-AI RESPONSE)

PSYCHOANALYSIS

OF TONY SOPRANO'S GHOST

FROM:

THE

YOUNG SOPRANOS

J. BECK

2024

cri·tique

/krəˈtēk/

noun

a detailed analysis and assessment of something, especially a literary, philosophical, or political theory.

"TONY SOPRANO"

(1959--2007)

Creating an exhaustive psychological profile of Tony Soprano, the protagonist of *The Sopranos* (1999–2007), requires analyzing his character through the lens of his actions, relationships, and therapy sessions as depicted in the original series canon.

Tony, portrayed by James Gandolfini, is a complex figure—a New Jersey mob boss navigating the pressures of his criminal empire and personal life.

Below is a detailed examination of his personality, psychological traits, disorders, motivations, and interpersonal dynamics, grounded in the show’s narrative and informed by psychological frameworks.

---

### **Overview of Tony Soprano**
- **Full Name**: Anthony John Soprano

- **Role**: Boss of the DiMeo crime family, husband, father of two (Meadow and Anthony Jr.)

- **Key Characteristics**: Charismatic, intelligent, volatile, introspective, manipulative, loyal yet ruthless, emotionally conflicted

- **Primary Conflicts**: Balancing his criminal and family lives, managing his mental health (panic attacks, depression), and grappling with existential questions about morality and identity

---

### **Personality Traits**
Tony exhibits a multifaceted personality shaped by his environment, upbringing, and role as a mob boss.

Using the **Big Five Personality Traits** as a framework, we can describe him as follows:

1. **Openness to Experience**: Moderate to High

- Tony is curious and reflective, as seen in his therapy sessions with Dr. Jennifer Melfi, where he explores his emotions, dreams, and childhood. He’s open to self-examination, though often resistant to change.
His interest in history (e.g., watching *The History Channel*) and occasional philosophical musings suggest intellectual curiosity.

   - However, his openness is limited by his rigid adherence to the mafia’s code and traditional values, which stifle personal growth.

2. **Conscientiousness**: Moderate

- Tony is highly organized and goal-oriented in his professional life, meticulously managing his criminal operations (e.g., strategizing against rivals like Phil Leotardo). He values duty and loyalty, both to his family and his “family.”

- Conversely, his impulsivity (e.g., violent outbursts, affairs) and procrastination in addressing personal issues (e.g., his marriage to Carmela) indicate lower conscientiousness in his personal life.

3. **Extraversion**: High

- Tony is charismatic, commanding, and socially dominant, traits essential to his leadership role. He thrives in social settings, whether intimidating subordinates or charming others (e.g., his flirtations with women like Gloria Trillo).

- However, he often retreats into isolation when overwhelmed, suggesting an introverted side amplified by stress or guilt.

4. **Agreeableness**: Low to Moderate

- Tony can be warm and generous, especially with his children, Meadow and AJ, or loyal allies like Paulie Walnuts. He shows empathy in select moments (e.g., his distress over killing Pussy Bonpensiero).

- Yet, his ruthlessness, manipulativeness, and tendency to prioritize self-interest (e.g., ordering hits without hesitation) reflect low agreeableness. His interactions often involve power dynamics rather than genuine cooperation.

5. **Neuroticism**: High

- Tony’s emotional instability is a cornerstone of his character. He suffers from panic attacks, depression, and anxiety, triggered by stressors like his mother’s manipulations, business conflicts, or fear of betrayal. His therapy sessions reveal deep-seated insecurity and fear of losing control.

- His volatile temper (e.g., beating up Bobby Baccalieri or lashing out at Carmela) underscores his struggle to regulate emotions.

---

### **Psychological Disorders and Symptoms**

Tony’s mental health is a central theme in *The Sopranos*, explored through his therapy with Dr. Melfi. Below are the key psychological issues he exhibits, supported by examples from the series:

1. **Panic Disorder**
   - **Symptoms**: Tony experiences recurrent panic attacks characterized by sudden, overwhelming anxiety, shortness of breath, and fainting. These are triggered by specific stimuli (e.g., the sight of meat in “Cold Stones” or memories of his childhood) or general stress (e.g., conflicts with Junior or Carmela).

- **Cause**: Dr. Melfi links these attacks to unresolved trauma from his childhood, particularly his mother Livia’s emotional abuse and his father’s violent lifestyle. The attacks often symbolize his fear of vulnerability or losing control.

- **Evidence**: His first panic attack in the pilot episode occurs after a stressful encounter with his uncle and a family barbecue, setting the stage for his therapy journey.

2. **Depression**
   - **Symptoms**: Tony displays signs of clinical depression, including low mood, anhedonia (loss of pleasure), and existential despair. He often questions the meaning of his life, as seen in his discussions about “the life” with Melfi or his envy of “normal” people.

- **Cause**: His depression likely stems from the cumulative stress of his dual life, guilt over his actions (e.g., killing Christopher Moltisanti), and unresolved grief (e.g., his mother’s death, despite their fraught relationship).

- **Evidence**: In “Cold Stones,” Tony’s bleak outlook during Meadow’s trip to Iceland and his somber reflections in therapy highlight his depressive tendencies.

3. **Antisocial Personality Disorder (ASPD)**
   - **Symptoms**: Tony meets several criteria for ASPD, including disregard for societal norms, deceitfulness, impulsivity, aggression, and lack of remorse for criminal acts (e.g., ordering murders like Adriana La Cerva’s).
He manipulates others effortlessly, as seen in his control over his crew or his gaslighting of Carmela.

- **Limitations**: While Tony exhibits sociopathic traits, he deviates from a full ASPD diagnosis due to his capacity for remorse and attachment.
He feels guilt over certain actions (e.g., Tony Blundetto’s death) and shows loyalty to his family, suggesting a moral conflict absent in classic sociopathy.

- **Evidence**: His cold-blooded decisions (e.g., killing Ralph Cifaretto) contrast with moments of emotional vulnerability, such as crying over his horse Pie-O-My’s death.

4. **Narcissistic Personality Disorder (NPD) Traits**
   - **Symptoms**: Tony displays grandiosity, a need for admiration, and a sense of entitlement, common in narcissistic individuals.
He expects loyalty and deference from his crew and reacts poorly to challenges to his authority (e.g., his rage at Feech LaManna’s insubordination).

- **Interpersonal Impact**: His narcissism strains relationships, particularly with Carmela, whom he expects to tolerate his infidelity while maintaining her role as the dutiful wife. His entitlement also fuels his affairs, as he seeks validation from women like Gloria or Valentina.

- **Evidence**: In “Amour Fou,” Tony’s affair with Gloria reflects his need for admiration, while his therapy sessions reveal a fragile ego beneath his bravado.

5. **Complex Trauma**
   - **Symptoms**: Tony’s childhood exposure to his father’s violence (e.g., witnessing Johnny Boy Soprano’s brutality) and his mother’s emotional neglect and manipulation contribute to complex trauma.
This manifests in his panic attacks, difficulty trusting others, and fear of abandonment.

- **Evidence**: Flashbacks in “Down Neck” and “Cold Stones” show young Tony witnessing his father’s criminal acts and Livia’s coldness, which Dr. Melfi ties to his anxiety and identity conflicts.

6. **Substance Abuse**
   - **Symptoms**: Tony engages in heavy drinking and occasional drug use (e.g., cocaine with Adriana in “All Due Respect”), which exacerbate his emotional instability and impulsivity.

- **Evidence**: His binge drinking after conflicts (e.g., post-separation from Carmela) and reliance on alcohol to cope with stress indicate a problematic relationship with substances.

---

### **Motivations and Conflicts**
Tony’s actions are driven by a mix of survival instincts, loyalty, and personal desires, often in conflict with one another:

1. **Power and Control**
   - As a mob boss, Tony’s primary motivation is maintaining control over his criminal empire.

He navigates threats from rivals (e.g., New York’s Lupertazzi family), internal betrayals (e.g., Pussy’s cooperation with the FBI), and law enforcement.

- His need for control extends to his personal life, where he dominates his family dynamics, often clashing with Carmela’s independence or Meadow’s rebellion.

2. **Family and Loyalty**
   - Tony’s devotion to his nuclear family (Carmela, Meadow, AJ) is genuine but fraught. He wants to provide for them and shield them from his criminal world, yet his actions (e.g., infidelity, violence) undermine this goal.

- His loyalty to his mafia “family” creates constant tension, as he must balance personal attachments with ruthless decision-making (e.g., killing Tony Blundetto to appease Phil Leotardo).

3. **Self-Preservation vs. Self-Destruction**
   - Tony’s survival instincts drive his strategic decisions, but his impulsivity and emotional volatility lead to self-destructive behaviors, such as affairs, violent outbursts, or alienating allies.

- His therapy sessions reflect a desire for self-understanding, but his resistance to change (e.g., dismissing Melfi’s insights about his mother) perpetuates his inner turmoil.

4. **Existential Search for Meaning**
   - Tony grapples with questions about his purpose and morality, particularly in later seasons.

His coma dream in “Join the Club” and “Mayham” (Season 6) symbolizes his fear of death and judgment, revealing a subconscious desire for redemption he cannot fully embrace.

- His envy of “normal” people (e.g., his fascination with Dr. Melfi’s stability) underscores his dissatisfaction with his life, despite its material rewards.

---

### **Interpersonal Dynamics**
Tony’s relationships reveal his psychological complexity, as he oscillates between warmth, manipulation, and violence:

1. **With Carmela Soprano (Wife)**
   - Tony loves Carmela but undermines their marriage through infidelity and emotional unavailability.

His affairs (e.g., Irina, Gloria) reflect his need for validation, while his attempts to reconcile with Carmela show genuine remorse.

- Their dynamic is a power struggle, with Carmela asserting her agency (e.g., pursuing divorce in Season 5) and Tony using charm or intimidation to maintain control.

2. **With Meadow and AJ (Children)**
   - Tony is protective and proud of Meadow, seeing her as his legacy. However, her growing independence and awareness of his criminal life create tension (e.g., her questioning his business in “College”).

- With AJ, Tony is frustrated by his son’s lack of ambition and emotional fragility, projecting his own fears of failure onto him (e.g., berating AJ in “Cold Stones”).

3. **With Dr. Jennifer Melfi (Therapist)**
   - Tony’s relationship with Melfi is his most introspective, as she provides a safe space to explore his vulnerabilities.

However, he resists her insights when they challenge his identity (e.g., rejecting her suggestion that Livia has borderline personality disorder).

- His attraction to Melfi reflects his need for a maternal figure who is both nurturing and unattainable, complicating their therapeutic alliance.

4. **With His Crew**
   - Tony commands loyalty through charisma and fear, but his relationships with subordinates like Christopher, Paulie, and Silvio are strained by mistrust and power dynamics.

He genuinely cares for them but prioritizes the organization’s survival (e.g., killing Christopher in “Kennedy and Heidi” after his drug relapse).

- His mentorship of younger members like Bobby Baccalieri shows a paternal side, though it’s often overshadowed by his ruthlessness.

5. **With Livia Soprano (Mother)**
   - Tony’s fraught relationship with Livia is central to his psychological issues. Her emotional manipulation and passive-aggressive behavior (e.g., plotting against Tony in Season 1) contribute to his trauma and panic attacks.

- Even after her death, Livia’s influence lingers, as Tony grapples with her legacy in therapy and dreams.

---

### **Defense Mechanisms**
Tony employs several psychological defense mechanisms to cope with stress and guilt:

- **Denial**: He denies the moral implications of his actions, framing his criminality as “just business” (e.g., justifying Adriana’s murder).

- **Projection**: He projects his insecurities onto others, such as blaming Carmela for their marital issues or AJ for his failures.

- **Rationalization**: Tony rationalizes his violence as necessary for survival, as seen in his justification for killing Pussy or Ralph.

- **Sublimation**: His therapy sessions and occasional hobbies (e.g., caring for animals like Pie-O-My) channel his emotions into less destructive outlets.

---

### **Developmental Background**
Tony’s psyche is rooted in his upbringing:

- **Childhood Trauma**: Growing up in a mafia family exposed Tony to violence (e.g., witnessing his father’s brutality) and emotional neglect from Livia, who was manipulative and unloving. His father, Johnny Boy, modeled toxic masculinity and criminality, shaping Tony’s worldview.

- **Cultural Influences**: The Italian-American subculture and mafia code reinforced values of loyalty, machismo, and secrecy, which Tony internalizes but also questions.

- **Education and Potential**: Tony’s intelligence (e.g., his brief college stint) suggests untapped potential, but his environment pulled him into organized crime, fostering a sense of entrapment.

---

### **Therapeutic Progress and Limitations**
Tony’s therapy with Dr. Melfi is a double-edged sword:

- **Progress**: He gains insight into his panic attacks, childhood trauma, and relational patterns. Therapy helps him manage stress and avoid some impulsive decisions (e.g., refraining from killing Carmela’s cousin in “Cold Stones”).

- **Limitations**: Tony’s resistance to change and manipulation of therapy (e.g., using insights to become a better criminal) limit his growth. Melfi’s eventual decision to end their sessions in “The Blue Comet” reflects her realization that Tony may be untreatable due to his sociopathic tendencies.

---

### **Existential and Moral Themes**
Tony’s psychological profile is inseparable from the show’s exploration of morality, identity, and the American Dream:

- **Moral Ambiguity**: Tony is neither a hero nor a villain but a deeply flawed human. His capacity for love and guilt coexists with his capacity for violence, making him a compelling study in moral complexity.

- **Existential Angst**: His coma dream and therapy sessions reveal a fear of death and a yearning for meaning, which he struggles to reconcile with his lifestyle.

- **American Dream**: Tony’s pursuit of wealth and status mirrors the American Dream, but his criminal path and personal dissatisfaction highlight its hollowness.

---

### **Conclusion**
Tony Soprano is a psychologically rich character defined by contradictions: a powerful leader plagued by vulnerability, a loving father capable of heinous acts, and a man seeking redemption while entrenched in sin.

His panic disorder, depression, and antisocial/narcissistic traits stem from a traumatic childhood, a high-stress lifestyle, and an inability to reconcile his dual identities.

Therapy offers him glimpses of self-awareness, but his resistance to change and the demands of his world prevent true transformation. Tony’s complexity makes him a timeless figure, embodying the struggle between self-destruction and the search for meaning.

To determine whether Tony Soprano is Machiavellian or a "pretender" as AJ claims in *The Sopranos* (assuming "Young Sopranos" refers to AJ’s perspective within the original series canon, as there’s no canonical spin-off by that name), we need to analyze Tony’s behavior, motivations, and alignment with Machiavellian principles, while addressing AJ’s accusation that Tony’s kindness, love, and loyalty are mere facades masking cruelty, deceit, and harm.

Below, I’ll evaluate Tony’s character through these lenses, grounding the analysis in the original series canon (1999–2007) and addressing each point raised.

---

### **Is Tony Soprano Machiavellian?**
Machiavellianism, as derived from Niccolò Machiavelli’s *The Prince*, describes a pragmatic, cunning, and often amoral approach to leadership, prioritizing power, control, and survival over ethics.

A Machiavellian leader is strategic, manipulative, and willing to use deception or force to achieve goals, while maintaining an appearance of virtue to secure loyalty. Let’s assess Tony against these traits:

1. **Strategic Manipulation and Deception**

   - **Evidence**: Tony frequently employs deception to maintain power. He hides behind Uncle Junior as a front boss in Seasons 1–2 to deflect FBI attention, presenting Junior as the figurehead while pulling the strings (e.g., orchestrating decisions in “Pax Soprana”).

Later, he uses Bobby Baccalieri and others to shield himself from scrutiny, as seen in Season 6 when he avoids direct confrontation with New York’s Lupertazzi family.

- **Machiavellian Alignment**: This aligns with Machiavelli’s advice to “appear merciful, faithful, humane, religious, upright” while being prepared to act otherwise when necessary (Chapter XVIII). Tony’s use of front bosses reflects a calculated strategy to protect his position, a hallmark of Machiavellian leadership.

2. **Ruthlessness for Power**
   - **Evidence**: Tony orders or commits murders to eliminate threats, even against those he claims to care about, such as Pussy Bonpensiero (“Funhouse”), Adriana La Cerva (“Long Term Parking”), and Christopher Moltisanti (“Kennedy and Heidi”). These acts prioritize the survival of his criminal empire over personal loyalty.

- **Machiavellian Alignment**: Machiavelli advocates that a leader “must not mind incurring the charge of cruelty for the purpose of keeping his subjects united and faithful” (Chapter XVII).

Tony’s willingness to kill allies to maintain control exemplifies this principle, even if it causes him guilt (e.g., his distress after Pussy’s death).

3. **Charisma and Appearance of Virtue**
   - **Evidence**: Tony projects an image of loyalty and care to his crew, family, and community, hosting lavish parties (e.g., Meadow’s graduation in “The Test Dream”) and providing for his children’s education. His charisma secures loyalty from subordinates like Paulie and Silvio, despite his betrayals.

- **Machiavellian Alignment**: Machiavelli emphasizes the importance of appearing virtuous to maintain loyalty, even if one’s actions contradict this image (Chapter XV).

Tony’s public persona as a devoted family man and generous boss masks his infidelity and violence, aligning with this tactic.

4. **Pragmatism Over Morality**
   - **Evidence**: Tony rationalizes his actions as necessary for survival, as seen in his justification for killing Tony Blundetto to appease Phil Leotardo (“All Due Respect”).

He navigates complex alliances (e.g., with New York) and internal betrayals (e.g., Richie Aprile) with a focus on outcomes over ethics.

- **Machiavellian Alignment**: Machiavelli argues that a leader must prioritize stability and power over moral purity. Tony’s pragmatic decisions, even when emotionally taxing, reflect this mindset.

**Conclusion on Machiavellianism**: Tony is undeniably Machiavellian. His strategic use of deception, willingness to employ violence, and maintenance of a virtuous facade align closely with Machiavelli’s principles.

However, his emotional conflicts—guilt, depression, and genuine care for his family—add complexity, distinguishing him from a purely cold-blooded Machiavellian figure like, say, a cartoonish villain. His humanity makes his Machiavellian tactics more nuanced but no less effective.

---

### **Is Tony a “Pretender” as AJ Claims?**
AJ’s accusation (likely reflecting his perspective in episodes like “Cold Stones” or “Made in America,” where he expresses disillusionment with his father) suggests that Tony’s displays of kindness, love, and fidelity are hypocritical, masking a mean, hateful, and deceitful core. Let’s evaluate this claim by examining Tony’s behavior in key areas:

1. **Pretending to Be Kind, Loving, and Faithful**

- **Evidence of Pretense**:
     - **Infidelity**:

Tony’s countless affairs (e.g., Irina, Gloria Trillo, Valentina) contradict his claims of loving Carmela. He maintains a facade of devotion while pursuing extramarital relationships, causing Carmela significant pain (e.g., their separation in Season 5).

- **Emotional Manipulation**: Tony often manipulates those he claims to love. For example, he gaslights Carmela during arguments (e.g., “Whitecaps”) and uses charm to placate Meadow’s suspicions about his criminal life (e.g., “College”).

- **Selective Kindness**: Tony’s generosity (e.g., funding Meadow’s education) often serves to maintain his image or control others, as when he pressures AJ to conform to his expectations (e.g., “Johnny Cakes”).


- **Counterevidence of Genuine Emotion**:
     - **Love for Family**:

Despite his flaws, Tony shows genuine affection for his children. He’s devastated by Meadow’s potential move to California (“Cold Stones”) and tries to protect AJ from his own failures, even if clumsily (e.g., pushing AJ into a job in “Made in America”).

- **Guilt and Vulnerability**: Tony’s therapy sessions reveal sincere guilt over his actions, such as his distress after killing Pussy or his grief over Pie-O-My’s death (“Whoever Did This”).

His panic attacks and depression suggest a man grappling with his contradictions, not merely pretending to feel.

- **Analysis**: Tony’s kindness and love are not entirely fake but are compromised by his selfishness and inability to prioritize others’ needs.

His infidelity and manipulation support AJ’s view of him as a pretender, but his genuine emotional struggles indicate that his positive traits are not wholly performative.

He’s a man torn between his desires and his duties, not a one-dimensional hypocrite.

2. **Pretending Not to Be the Boss**
   - **Evidence of Pretense**:

- Tony uses Junior as a front boss in Seasons 1–2 to shield himself from FBI scrutiny, as seen in “I Dream of Jeannie Cusamano,” where he manipulates Junior into taking the public role.

Later, he positions Bobby and others as buffers to distance himself from direct responsibility (e.g., during the war with New York in Season 6B).

- He downplays his authority in public, presenting himself as a “waste management consultant” to maintain a low profile (e.g., in interactions with civilians like Dr. Cusamano).

- **Counterevidence**:
- Within the DiMeo family, Tony’s authority is unquestioned by most. His crew knows he’s the real boss, and he asserts dominance when challenged (e.g., beating Ralph Cifaretto in “Whoever Did This” to reassert control).

- His use of front bosses is less about pretending to lack power and more about strategic self-preservation, a common mafia tactic to avoid legal consequences.

- **Analysis**: Tony’s use of front bosses aligns with AJ’s claim of pretense, but it’s less about denying his role and more about protecting it.

His deception is tactical, not a rejection of his identity as boss, which he embraces privately and among his crew.

3. **Harming or Killing Those He Claims to Care For**
   - **Evidence Supporting AJ’s Claim**:

- **Murders of Allies**: Tony orders or commits the deaths of close associates he claims to care about, including Pussy (“Funhouse”), Adriana (“Long Term Parking”), and Christopher (“Kennedy and Heidi”). These acts prioritize business over personal bonds.

- **Harm to Family**: Tony’s actions indirectly harm his family. His criminal lifestyle exposes Carmela to stress and danger (e.g., FBI raids), Meadow to moral conflicts (e.g., her rejection of a legal career in “Soprano Home Movies”), and AJ to emotional neglect (e.g., AJ’s suicide attempt in “The Second Coming”).

- **Betrayal of Trust**: Tony’s lies and infidelity betray Carmela’s trust, while his harsh parenting (e.g., berating AJ in “Cold Stones”) exacerbates his son’s insecurities.

- **Counterevidence**:
     - **Protective Instincts**:
Tony takes risks to protect his family, such as negotiating peace with New York to ensure their safety (e.g., “Stage 5”). He also tries to shield Meadow and AJ from his criminal world, encouraging their education and “legitimate” paths.

- **Guilt and Conflict**: Tony’s emotional turmoil after killing loved ones (e.g., his coma dream grappling with morality in “Mayham”) suggests he doesn’t harm others callously.

His actions are often driven by necessity within the mafia’s code, not hatred.

- **Analysis**: Tony’s pattern of harming or killing those he cares about supports AJ’s accusation, but it’s not driven by inherent cruelty or hatred.

The mafia’s ruthless demands force Tony to prioritize survival over loyalty, and his lifestyle’s collateral damage affects his family.

His guilt and attempts to protect them indicate that his harm is not intentional malice but a consequence of his choices.

---

### **Machiavellian vs. Pretender: Reconciling the Perspectives**

- **Machiavellian Perspective**: Tony’s actions align closely with Machiavellian principles. His use of deception (front bosses, public persona), ruthlessness (murders), and charisma (securing loyalty) reflect a leader who prioritizes power and survival, even at the cost of personal relationships.

His pretense—whether in appearing virtuous or downplaying his authority—is a strategic tool, not a sign of weakness or inauthenticity.

- **AJ’s Perspective (Pretender)**: AJ’s view highlights Tony’s hypocrisy and the gap between his words and actions.

To AJ, Tony’s claims of love and kindness are undermined by his infidelity, violence, and emotional unavailability, making him a “pretender” who hides his true, selfish nature.

This perspective captures Tony’s moral failings but overlooks the structural pressures of his role as a mob boss, which force him into difficult choices.

**Synthesis**: Tony is both Machiavellian and, to an extent, a pretender, but these are not mutually exclusive.

His Machiavellian tactics (deception, ruthlessness) are deliberate strategies to maintain power, aligning with his role as a mob boss.

However, AJ’s accusation of pretense holds weight in Tony’s personal life, where his claims of love and fidelity are contradicted by his actions.

The key distinction is intent: Tony’s pretense is often calculated for survival (Machiavellian), but his personal failings (infidelity, neglect) reflect human weakness rather than a purely hateful or deceitful core.

His emotional complexity—guilt, depression, and genuine care—complicates AJ’s view, suggesting that Tony’s “pretense” is partly a struggle to reconcile his conflicting identities as a criminal and a family man.

---

### **Conclusion**
Tony Soprano is fundamentally Machiavellian, employing strategic deception, ruthlessness, and charisma to maintain his power as a mob boss, as seen in his use of front bosses and elimination of threats like Pussy or Christopher.

However, AJ’s accusation of Tony as a “pretender” captures the hypocrisy in his personal life, where his infidelity and harm to loved ones undermine his claims of love and kindness.

While Tony’s actions often align with Machiavellian pragmatism, his emotional struggles and genuine care for his family suggest that his “pretense” is not purely deceitful but a flawed attempt to navigate irreconcilable roles.

Tony is neither a cartoonish villain nor a misunderstood hero but a complex figure whose Machiavellian strategies coexist with human vulnerabilities, making AJ’s view partially true but incomplete.